Reddit & Social Media: Why the Witchcraft Community Can Not Be Trusted

Reddit & Social Media: Why the Witchcraft Community Can Not Be Trusted

Reddit & Social Media: Why the Witchcraft Community Can Not Be Trusted

Witchcraft has always been a deeply personal and experiential practice, passed down through mentorship, initiations, and lived experiences. Yet, in the age of social media, particularly on platforms like Reddit, Twitter, and TikTok, misinformation runs rampant. Many self-proclaimed practitioners claim expertise after reading a few books or engaging in online discussions, pushing spells and advice that are not only inaccurate but often completely detached from authentic practice.

The reality? Most of what circulates in online witchcraft spaces lacks depth, discipline, and authenticity. Many in these spaces either unknowingly spread misinformation or deliberately posture as authorities to gain recognition. True practitioners—those with initiation, study, and real-world application—understand that authentic knowledge isn’t something freely handed out in a Reddit post.

Secrecy and Oaths: Why Real Witchcraft Knowledge Isn't Found on Reddit & Social Media

One of the biggest red flags in online witchcraft spaces is the ease with which rituals and spells are shared. Traditional witchcraft, especially within structured traditions, involves secrecy and commitment. Practitioners belonging to established covens or initiatory paths are often bound by oaths, meaning they cannot and will not share sacred knowledge with outsiders. If they did, they would face severe consequences—not just from their peers but from the very forces they work with.

Authentic witchcraft isn’t about quick-fix spells found on a forum. It’s about working with energies, spirits, and forces that require deep understanding and respect. When someone online claims to offer "ancient spells" or "100% guaranteed results," it’s almost always fraudulent. Those who possess real knowledge don’t advertise it so freely, and when they do offer services, they do so with the integrity and responsibility that comes with genuine experience.

The Ego Trap: How Reddit & Social Media Turn Witchcraft into a Popularity Contest

Reddit and other social media platforms thrive on engagement, and in the witchcraft community, that often translates to people trying to one-up each other with supposed knowledge. It’s not about authentic practice—it’s about who can sound the most impressive. This leads to misinformation being spread as fact, with people arguing over traditions they barely understand and attacking those who question them.

Even when correct information appears, it’s often drowned out by the sheer volume of individuals who are more interested in proving their own intelligence than genuinely learning. This creates an environment where beginners are led astray by self-proclaimed experts who, in reality, have no real experience beyond what they’ve read online.

The Problem with Social Media “Witches for Hire” on Reddit & Beyond

Another issue is the rise of professional witches advertising services on platforms like TikTok, Instagram, and Reddit. While some legitimate practitioners exist, many operate like fast-food businesses, offering spells on demand with unrealistic promises. Services that guarantee immediate wealth, love, or career success are almost always scams, preying on desperate individuals who don’t know any better.

Legitimate practitioners may advertise their work, but they don’t hype it up with extravagant claims, nor do they share sacred rituals or guarantee success. Real magical work requires effort from both the practitioner and the client—it isn’t instant, and it isn’t a one-size-fits-all service. If someone is selling spells like items on a restaurant menu, they’re likely pushing fantasy, not reality.

Conclusion: Reddit & Social Media Are the Worst Places to Learn Witchcraft

Witchcraft isn’t something that can be mastered through a few Reddit threads or social media posts. It’s a lifelong practice that requires dedication, study, and real-world application. The overwhelming majority of information found online—especially on Reddit—is either incomplete, misleading, or entirely false. Authentic practitioners know this, which is why they don’t freely share their most valuable knowledge in public forums.

If you’re serious about learning witchcraft, seek out real mentors, engage with established traditions, and most importantly, practice. Don’t rely on internet trends or self-proclaimed experts who prioritize online validation over real knowledge. The truth is, if someone were truly knowledgeable in the craft, they wouldn’t be posting their secrets on Reddit for free.